Why I Use a Dedicated Camera Even Though I Carry an iPhone and a Pixel

Every time I pull out my camera around friends, someone asks the same thing: “Why do you need that? Your phone has a great camera.”

It’s a fair question, and the person asking usually has a point. I’m not carrying one phone. I’m carrying two: an iPhone 17 and a Pixel 10 Pro. Between them I have ultra-wide lenses, a 5x telephoto, night modes, portrait blur and a zoom that Google says goes to 100x.

And yet roughly 90% of the photos I take come from neither of them. They come from a Fujifilm X-E5 with the tiny XF23mm f/2.8 pancake lens it comes with in the kit.

This isn’t a post about phones being bad at photography. They aren’t. It’s about why, for me, a phone camera and a real camera are different tools, and why the one I reach for when I actually want to make a photograph is the one with dials on top.

“The best camera is the one you have with you”

I believe this saying. A camera sitting in a drawer at home has never taken a good photograph.

It’s also the whole reason smartphone photography took over. Your phone is already in your pocket. There’s nothing extra to pack, no lens to choose, no settings to understand. You see something, you tap, and a very good image appears.

But I think the saying gets stretched too far. It answers the question “which camera will be there?” It doesn’t answer “which camera will make me want to take pictures?” Those turned out to be two different questions for me.

The easy answer to the first one is “my phone”. So I made the second answer just as easy: a camera small enough that it’s always there too. More on that later.

Let’s be clear: phones have become incredible

In the last decade, phone cameras went from “good enough for Instagram” to something that would have looked like science fiction in 2015. Here’s what my two phones are working with, on paper:

iPhone 17Pixel 10 ProFujifilm X-E5
Main sensor48MP Fusion camera, 26mm50MP, 1/1.3-inch sensor40.2MP APS-C X-Trans CMOS 5 HR
Other cameras48MP ultra-wide, 2x crop from main48MP ultra-wide, 48MP 5x telephotoInterchangeable lenses
ZoomUp to 10x digitalUp to 100x with Pro Res ZoomWhatever lens is mounted
StabilizationSensor-shift OISOIS5-axis IBIS, up to 7 stops (Fujifilm’s rating)
Physical photo controlsCamera Control buttonVolume/power keysShutter speed, exposure compensation and film simulation dials

The phones win on range and convenience. One device covers ultra-wide to telephoto, stacks multiple exposures for tricky light, and has a shareable photo ready before I’ve put it back in my pocket.

Some of that software is remarkable. Some of it deserves a closer look. The Pixel’s 100x Pro Res Zoom, for example, uses generative AI above 30x to rebuild detail the sensor never captured. I found that at the extreme end the results can feel “less of a photograph and more of a graphic”. Google does keep the original alongside the AI version, which I appreciate. But it tells you something about the philosophy: the phone’s goal is a pleasing image, whatever it takes to get there.

That goal is exactly right for most people, most of the time. It just isn’t what I’m after when I go out to photograph.

The thing a spec sheet can’t show: the process

This is the biggest reason, and the hardest one to explain to someone who hasn’t tried it.

I enjoy taking photos with the Fujifilm. Not just looking at them afterwards. The act of taking them.

Picking the camera up. The weight of it in my hand. Bringing it to my eye. Adjusting the scene, waiting for the light or for a person to walk into the right spot, and then pressing a real shutter button and hearing it click.

Sometimes I’ll shoot the same scene from a few slightly different angles. Sometimes I’ll change the aperture just to decide how much of the background stays sharp. It feels like I’m making a photograph rather than just capturing one.

With my phone, I get a photo. With the camera, I get a photo and the experience of making it. That second part is what’s missing when I shoot on my phone. The pictures are fine. The satisfaction isn’t there.

It might sound sentimental, but I think it’s practical too. If you enjoy the process, you do more of it. You go out more, you shoot more, and you get better. A tool you love using makes you a better photographer than a tool that’s merely capable.

Physical controls vs touchscreen sliders

I know phones offer manual control. The Pixel 10 Pro has “Pro controls” built into its camera app, and apps like Halide or ProCamera go further on the iPhone. You can set ISO, shutter speed, focus and white balance.

But doing it on a phone is, for me, miserable. Every setting lives behind a tap. You open a menu, drag a slider with your thumb, and try to keep the frame steady while your finger covers part of the screen. There’s no feel to it. You can’t change something without looking. Apple’s Camera Control button is a step in the right direction, but it’s still one pressure-sensitive strip cycling through one setting at a time.

The X-E5 is the opposite. It has a shutter speed dial, an exposure compensation dial, a film simulation dial, and two command dials. Each does one job, and each tells you its setting just by looking at it, even with the camera switched off.

That changes how I think while shooting. I always know what settings I’m using and what they’ll do to the image. If I want motion blur in a moving crowd, I turn the shutter dial down. If I want the shadows to stay dark, I dial in minus one on exposure. With a phone, those are decisions the software usually makes for me. With the camera, they’re mine.

And there’s the plain physical pleasure of it. A dial that clicks into place. A shutter button with a proper half-press. The sound of the shutter. None of this makes the photo sharper. All of it makes pressing the button feel like something happened.

What I see is what I get

There’s another difference I didn’t expect to care about: how the scene looks while I’m framing it.

On a phone, I’m holding a bright screen at arm’s length and looking at a live preview that isn’t quite the final photo. After I press the shutter, the phone stacks frames, tone-maps the highlights, lifts the shadows, sharpens and denoises. Sometimes the result looks better than the preview. Sometimes it just looks different. A soft, moody evening can come out brighter and flatter than it felt, because the phone decided the shadows needed rescuing.

With the X-E5, I put my eye to the viewfinder and the rest of the world disappears. The electronic viewfinder shows the exposure and the film simulation I’ve chosen, so what I see is very close to what I’ll get. The framing feels truer to life, and the photo on the card matches the moment I remember.

Neither way of shooting is wrong. A phone held at arm’s length invites a quick grab; a camera at your eye invites you to stop and compose. For the kind of photography I enjoy, I want the second.

Shooting with one prime lens helps too. The XF23mm gives the same field of view as a 35mm lens on full frame, a little tighter than the iPhone 17’s 26mm main camera. Fujifilm describes it as close to human vision, and that’s how it feels to me: the frame looks like the scene I’m standing in, without the stretched wide-angle look a phone can give up close. With a single fixed focal length, I stop thinking about which camera mode to pick and start thinking about where to stand. If I want a tighter shot, I walk closer. That constraint has done more for my composition than any zoom ever did.

The problem with shooting RAW on a phone

The usual counter-argument is: “Just shoot RAW on your phone and edit it.” I’ve tried. It doesn’t fit how I want to take photos, for four reasons.

  1. It’s not always available where you’d expect. The Pixel 10 Pro can save RAW from its own camera app. My iPhone 17, as a non-Pro model, doesn’t get Apple ProRAW in the stock Camera app, so I’d need a third-party app just to start.
  2. RAW means homework. A RAW file is the unprocessed sensor data. That flexibility is the point, but it also means every photo needs editing before it looks finished. Often I don’t have the time, or I don’t want to turn a walk into an editing session.
  3. Mobile editing still feels like a compromise to me. Apps like Lightroom Mobile exist and are capable, but I’ve never found editing RAW files on a small touchscreen as comfortable or precise as doing it on a laptop.
  4. A phone screen isn’t an editing environment. Phone displays are bright and often good, but auto-brightness, warm night-time colour shifts and a six-inch canvas make it hard to judge colour and tone consistently. So the RAW files end up going to a laptop anyway.

By that point, the phone’s biggest advantage, instant results, is gone.

Film simulations: the reason I shoot JPEG

This is where Fujifilm solves the problem for me.

Fujifilm cameras have film simulations: colour and tone profiles built on the company’s decades of making film stock. The X-E5 has 20 of them, including Classic Chrome, Classic Negative, Acros and the newer Reala Ace. Each one changes how colours, contrast and skin tones are rendered in the JPEG the camera produces.

On top of that, you can tweak the finer details: grain, highlight and shadow tone, colour, white balance shift, clarity and more. The photography community calls these combinations film recipes, and thousands of them are shared online, each designed to mimic a particular look or film stock.

The X-E5 makes this physical. It has a dedicated film simulation dial on the top plate, with three custom positions (FS1, FS2 and FS3) where I can save my own recipes. Want a warm, faded look for a sunny afternoon? One turn. Black and white for the evening? Another turn.

That changes the workflow completely. I decide how the photo should look before I press the shutter, not in an app hours later. When I get home, the JPEGs are already finished. No import-edit-export routine. No “I’ll edit these later” folder quietly filling up and never getting opened.

JPEG isn’t a compromise

For a long time, “serious” photography meant shooting RAW. And RAW still has a place. For paid work, difficult mixed lighting or photos I know I’ll want to push hard, I want every bit of data.

But most of my photos are everyday moments and things that catch my eye. For those, a good JPEG with a look I’ve already chosen is exactly what I want. The question that matters isn’t “which file has the most editing latitude?” It’s “which photo will I actually keep, share and look back on?” For me, that’s the finished Fujifilm JPEG, far more often than the RAW file I promised myself I’d edit.

A camera that slows me down (in a good way)

My phones make photography fast. I can take ten shots in three seconds and pick one later.

The Fujifilm is slower, and that’s part of the appeal. I look at the scene, move a step to the left, check the light, adjust a dial, and sometimes decide the shot isn’t worth taking at all. That small bit of friction makes me pay attention.

Slowing down doesn’t automatically make better photos. But it makes me more engaged, and I tend to value the photos I made carefully more than the ones I sprayed and picked from.

Why size matters more than specs

None of this would work if my camera were a big body with a heavy zoom lens. That’s the kind of kit that stays at home, which brings us right back to the “best camera” problem.

The X-E5 with the XF23mm f/2.8 is compact and light enough that I take it everywhere. It doesn’t feel like extra equipment; it feels like part of what I carry. So on a normal day, I have the iPhone, the Pixel and the Fujifilm with me. It sounds excessive, but each has a job. The phones are always connected, always ready and endlessly versatile. The Fujifilm is the one I choose when I want to photograph.

That distinction matters. I’m not carrying the camera because my phones can’t take good photos. I’m carrying it because I want to use a camera.

Where my phones still win

I’m not dogmatic about this. There are plenty of situations where a phone is the better tool:

  • Reach. When I need serious zoom, the Pixel’s 5x telephoto goes where my 23mm pancake can’t.
  • Hard light, no time. In tricky lighting when I need a shot right now, the phone’s multi-frame processing gets a usable result without me thinking about exposure.
  • Utility shots. Receipts, documents, a sign I want to remember. That’s phone work.
  • Instant sharing. If a photo needs to be on WhatsApp or Instagram in ten seconds, the phone wins.
  • Discretion. Some places a dedicated camera feels out of place. A phone doesn’t.
  • Video. For casual clips, a phone’s stabilization and processing are hard to beat.
  • The camera isn’t with me. Then the phone is the best camera, full stop.

That’s the 10%. And I’m happy the phones handle it so well.

So, should you buy a dedicated camera?

Probably not, if your phone already gives you photos you love and you enjoy taking them. That’s exactly what a camera is supposed to do.

But it might be worth it if:

  • You feel something is missing when you shoot on your phone, even when the photos look fine.
  • You want to control exposure and understand why a photo looks the way it does.
  • You like the idea of choosing a look in-camera instead of editing afterwards.
  • You want photography to feel like a hobby, not another thing you do on your phone.

If that sounds like you, the most important spec isn’t megapixels. It’s size. Buy something small enough that you’ll actually carry it.

The real reason I carry a camera

After living with both, I’ve realised my reason has little to do with proving the camera takes “better” photos. On pure image quality, my phones are closer than people think, and in some situations they’re ahead.

I carry the Fujifilm because I enjoy photography more with it. I like holding it, looking through the viewfinder, turning dials, hearing the shutter, and coming home with JPEGs that already look the way I intended.

My phones are the cameras I always have. The Fujifilm is the camera I want to use. And sometimes the best camera isn’t the one you have with you. It’s the one that makes you want to go out and take photos in the first place.